The Status of God in the 21st Century

 

On Thursday, April 25, 2013, Etcetera held an open discussion entitled “The Status of God in the 21st Century,” an in-depth look at our relationship with – and the relevancy of – God, religion and spirituality in 2013. Presenters were Justin Schieber and Scott Smith.

Justin Schieber is an ex-Christian and active member of CFI Michigan who enjoys promoting critical thought – more specifically, a friendly yet firm skepticism towards religious claims. Justin co-hosts the radio show and podcast titled “Reasonable Doubts – Your Skeptical Guide to Religion.”

Scott Smith is a lifelong Christian and an active member of Church of the Living God in Traverse City. He enjoys blogging and teaching on Christian theology and defense as well as engaging skeptics in debate regarding Christian truth claims. Scott is a co-founder of Etcetera as well as TC Apologetics, a local club committed to the defense of the faith.

 

The Shape of Reality: Are We Really Free?

“Your worldview has to have the same shape that reality does.”  – J. Budziszewski

As noted in the opening post in this series,  I believe Christianity offers compelling reasons to believe that truth is found most fully and consistently within the framework of a Christian worldview. The second post addressed the need for an objective foundation for morality. Of course, using the language of morality only makes sense if we are moral beings – that is, if we are significant moral agents who have an obligation to choose good and avoid evil.  This can only happen if we are free to make that choice, and therein lies another key question: Are we really free?

Generally, people believe that at some point everyone freely chooses  to make good and/or bad choices. Jaegwon Kim, philosopher at Brown University, has noted, “We commonly think that we, as persons, have a mental and bodily dimension….Something like this dualism of personhood, I believe, is common lore shared across most cultures and religious traditions.”1  Mind and Language published a paper in 2010 entitled “Is Belief in Free Will a Cultural Universal?” After studying a broad sample of people in the United States, Hong Kong, India and Columbia,

“The results revealed a striking degree of cross-cultural convergence. In all four cultural groups, the majority of participants said that (a) our universe is indeterministic and (b) moral responsibility is not compatible with determinism.” 

Consensus is not an air-tight way to arrive at truth, of course, but it is an insightful way to see what experiences humanity in general share. Most people believe we exercise some form of free will.

Not everyone agrees. When Rodney Brooks and Rosalind Picard debated the question, “Can Robots Become Human?” at a Veritas Forum at MIT in 2007, the following exchange took place2 :

Brooks: “ I think of myself as a robot, as a bag of skin full of biomolecules, and if I step back, that’s what [my wife] is, that’s what my kids are. But I have this completely different way of interacting with them, with unconditional love, which is not part of that scientific view. So I have multiple views I operate under every day.”

Picard: “I don’t just call those multiple views, I call those inconsistent views…so there’s no purpose, there’s no meaning, there’s no free will.”

Brooks: “That’s why I said I have a set of inconsistent views that I live under, because that’s really desolate, but it’s the truth.”

Picard: “Yeah, that does seem pretty desolate, and I wonder how you – why you care?”

Brooks: “I live in a fantasyland. That’s the fantasyland I’ve chosen to live in…”

So what is actually happening? Continue Reading…

  1. from Bioethics, Substance Dualism and the Argument from Self-Awareness, by J.P. Moreland []
  2. as recorded in “Living Machines” and published in A Place For Truth []

Back to the Cross

What is apologetics? What is my role as a Christian? Jay Watts answers these questions and many more in his talk entitled, “Back to the Cross”, delivered Sunday morning, April 28, 2013 at Church of the Living God in Traverse City, MI.

 

The Shape of Reality: Identifying Evil

“Your worldview has to have the same shape that reality does.”                     – J. Budziszewski

As noted in the opening post in this series,  I believe Christianity offers compelling reasons to believe that truth is found most fully and consistently within the framework of a Christian worldview. Considering some recent front page headlines, it seems appropriate to begin by looking specifically at ethics and morality.

In the aftermath of the Penn State scandal, everyone agreed that a long-standing taboo ought to remain: child molestation is not good. The recent case involving Dr. Gossnell’s butchery of newborn children, as well as the bombings at the Boston Marathon, have engendered an additional outcry against the presence of moral evil in the world.

People from all walks of life have found common ground in their stand against this type of injustice.  However, it is increasingly difficult to find a consistent explanation for why these are examples of objectively bad things – that is, actions that are wrong irregardless of individual feelings and preferences. Continue Reading…

WTCM Radio Interview

Friday, April 26, 2013, Norm Jones of WTCM, Newstalk 580 interviewed Jay Watts about his upcoming visit to Traverse City. Check it out here!

Page 1 of 2312345»1020...Last »